Long Island’s Home Court Advantage

Most All-Long Island Players

Every school that has produced a Newsday All-Long Island First Team player, ranked by how many different players it has put on the First Team, with each school’s total All-Long Island players alongside — 1963–2026.

The list is ranked by unique First Team players — each player counted once, however many times he was picked. Alongside it sits each school’s total unique All-Long Island players: every different player the school has placed on the First Team or the Second Team, again counted once. In all, 129 schools have put a player on an All-Long Island team; 98 of them have produced a First Teamer. Schools tied on unique First Team players share a rank.

All-Long Island players by school, 1963–2026

Ranked by unique First Team players, with each school’s total unique All-Long Island players (First Team and Second Team combined) alongside. The top 10 schools are shaded.

Rank School Unique First Team Players Total All-Long Island Players
1Long Island Lutheran4059
2Hempstead2329
3Amityville1728
3Uniondale1728
5Brentwood1624
5St. Agnes1621
7Holy Trinity1522
8Malverne1425
9Bay Shore1321
9St. Dominic1320
11Chaminade1222
11St. Anthony's1221
13Baldwin1122
14St. Mary's1023
15North Babylon916
15South Side916
15Westbury921
15Whitman912
19Center Moriches713
19Copiague712
19Southampton714
22Bridgehampton610
22Elmont611
22Half Hollow Hills West612
22Harborfields67
22Manhasset617
22St. John the Baptist611
22Westhampton66
22Wyandanch610
30Bellport510
30Deer Park57
30East Hampton511
30Floyd58
30Lawrence Woodmere Academy510
30Long Beach511
30Longwood58
37Farmingdale46
37Freeport49
37Kings Park47
37Northport49
37Oceanside46
37Smithtown West46
43Carle Place35
43Great Neck North35
43Great Neck South35
43Greenport38
43Half Hollow Hills East310
43Lawrence310
43Lynbrook38
43Patchogue34
43Roosevelt311
43Roslyn35
43Sachem38
43West Babylon35
55Babylon25
55Carey23
55Central Islip26
55Cold Spring Harbor22
55Floral Park27
55Glen Cove27
55Kellenberg26
55Lindenhurst27
55Massapequa24
55Miller Place24
55Oyster Bay24
55Plainview JFK22
55Port Jefferson23
68Bayport-Blue Point13
68Calhoun13
68Commack13
68Comsewogue15
68Connetquot12
68East Islip11
68Friends Academy15
68Herricks11
68Hewlett14
68Hicksville11
68Holy Family11
68Huntington12
68Islip13
68Jericho18
68Locust Valley12
68Mepham11
68Mineola11
68North Shore13
68Our Savior New American11
68Pierson13
68Plainview-Old Bethpage JFK11
68Port Washington11
68Portledge13
68Riverhead11
68Seaford12
68Seton Hall11
68Sewanhaka11
68Southold11
68Ward Melville14
68West Hempstead13
68Wheatley14

No school in the list matches that search.

About This List

Compiled from Newsday’s All-Long Island teams database.

The rankings cover 1963–2026 and include the complete 2025 pick class, taken from Newsday’s published 2025 First and Second Teams — Newsday’s database itself omits that class.

No player in the database holds more than three First Team selections at one school. The three-time First Teamers include Matt Cajuste (Jericho), Achraf Yacoubou and Devonte Green (Long Island Lutheran), Mamadou Diakhate and Joel Suarez (St. Mary’s), Tim Doyle (St. Dominic), Maurice Manning (Bridgehampton) and Patrick Burke (Smithtown West).