Cascione and Leary: All-New York State in Three Sports
Long Island produced two players last season who were All-New York State in three different sports — Smithtown West’s Michael Cascione in basketball, football and baseball, and Carle Place’s Ryan Leary in basketball, football and soccer. Cascione was also a Team Long Island selection in basketball.
Long Island produced two players last season that were All-New York State in three different sports.
Smithtown West’s Michael Cascione earned his honors in basketball, football and baseball. Carle Place’s Ryan Leary earned his in basketball, football and soccer. Both were Newsday First Team All-Long Island picks in basketball, and both were named a Newsday Player of the Year.
Michael Cascione — Smithtown West
Cascione’s sweep came in basketball, football and baseball — and he was a First Team All-State selection in all three sports, on his way to one of the most decorated senior years on Long Island in 2025-26.
On the Court
Basketball is where Cascione made his biggest mark. He was named to the NYSSWA Class AA All-State First Team and Newsday’s All-Long Island First Team, and Newsday named him its Suffolk County Player of the Year. He averaged 24.1 points, 11.1 rebounds, 5.2 assists and 3.0 steals a game as a senior, shot 53.5 percent from the field, and finished his career with 1,383 points. He was also the League 3 Player of the Year and an All-County selection.
Smithtown West went 81-11 over Cascione’s career, winning three league titles and reaching three Suffolk finals. In 2025-26 the Bulls broke through for the first Suffolk County and Long Island championships in program history — and Cascione scored 30 points on his 18th birthday in the 65-50 win over South Side at Farmingdale State that delivered the Long Island title. As a junior, he had already averaged 20.4 points a game and earned All-State honorable mention.
On the Gridiron
In the fall, Cascione was a First Team All-State and First Team All-Long Island defensive back. He recorded five interceptions as a senior, won the Tom Cassese Award as Suffolk County’s top defensive back, and was named the 2025 New York All-Region Defensive Player of the Year. He was also a finalist for the Hansen Award as Suffolk’s most outstanding player, the Cipp Award as the county’s top running back, and the Burnett Award as the county’s best defensive player.
On the Diamond
In the spring, Cascione was a First Team All-State shortstop who won his league’s Silver Slugger Award and earned All-County honors. As a junior he hit .407 with 30 stolen bases. Across all three seasons, he was a finalist for the Butch Dellecave Award.
A Team Long Island Selection — Now at Hofstra
Cascione’s basketball roots run through Long Island’s own programs: he was a Team Long Island selection, representing Long Island at the Nike IS8 Tournament in New York City, and he played AAU basketball for Premier Basketball of Hauppauge.
Hofstra announced his signing on July 8, 2026, and he is now a freshman wearing No. 0 for head coach Speedy Claxton, the Hempstead native. Cascione is the 25th player in Team Long Island’s 14-year history to play NCAA Division I basketball — and only the third player from a Smithtown high school to do it, after Chris Rooney (American University) and Phil Black (Yale).
Ryan Leary — Carle Place
Leary’s sweep came in basketball, football and soccer — and basketball is where the Carle Place senior made his biggest mark.
On the court, Leary was named to the NYSSWA Class B All-State First Team as a senior — and as a junior, too; he was a four-time All-State selection overall. Newsday named him to its All-Long Island First Team and made him its overall Player of the Year for 2025-26. He was also the Nassau County Small Schools Player of the Year and a four-time All-County selection, he led Long Island in scoring at 29.9 points per game, and he finished as Carle Place’s all-time leading scorer.
On the football field, Leary was an All-State, All-County and All-Region selection, and a First Team All-Long Island pick.
On the soccer pitch, he was a two-time All-State selection and a First Team All-Long Island pick — and a New York State champion.
Leary also played for Team Long Island in a summer charity tournament that raised money for the families of police officers killed in the line of duty. He is now at Pace University, where he is playing both football and basketball.