Newsday’s 2025-26 All-Long Island boys basketball teams were built around a deep senior class, and nearly all of them are now on college rosters for 2026-27. The group is led by Newsday’s two Players of the Year — Player of the Year Ryan Leary of Carle Place, now at Pace, and Suffolk County Player of the Year Michael Cascione of Smithtown West, now at Hofstra. Here is where every All-Long Island senior landed.
First Team
- Ryan Leary, Carle Place → Pace (D2)Newsday’s Player of the Year; Long Island’s leading scorer in 2025-26 at 29.9 points per game.
- Michael Cascione, Smithtown West → Hofstra (D1)Newsday’s Suffolk County Player of the Year.
- Amir Dickerson, Amityville → Chattanooga State CC (NJCAA)Wearing No. 23 as a freshman point guard at Chattanooga State.
- Kyle Dillon, Chaminade → Wesleyan (D3)Named on Chaminade’s official college signing list for the Class of 2026.
- Corey Faines, Bay Shore → Nazareth (D3)Committed to Nazareth to play basketball and study business.
- Brendan Martin, Floral Park → Farmingdale State (D3)Averaged 21.9 points and hit 76 three-pointers in 2025-26.
- Melo Mojeed, St. Dominic → Queens College (D2)On Queens’ roster as a freshman guard out of Valley Stream and St. Dominic.
- Alex Franklin, Southampton → SUNY Cortland (D3)Southampton’s all-time leading scorer.
- Tristan Thomas, Holy Trinity → Molloy (D2)Senior forward on Holy Trinity’s 2026 state championship team.
Second Team
- Jack Bell, Walt Whitman → Ursinus (D3)Averaged 20.9 points, about 16 rebounds and 4 blocks as a senior.
- Myles Herbert, St. Mary’s → SUNY Maritime (D3)Averaged 14.6 points, 5.7 rebounds and 5.1 assists as a senior.
- Ethan Sainsbury, Baldwin → West Nottingham Academy (post-grad)Averaged 12.7 points, 7.4 assists, 4.7 rebounds and 3.9 steals as a senior; the first four-year Baldwin player to win four Nassau titles. Taking a post-grad year in Maryland and reclassified to the class of 2027.
- Ethan Saintjean, Hills West → No college basketball destinationAveraged 15 points, 6.7 assists, 4.2 rebounds and 3.1 steals as a senior; a captain and a top-10 all-time scorer at Hills West. Reclassified to the class of 2027 for baseball, with a Georgia Premier Academy affiliation, and is currently uncommitted.
- Cameron Serrano, North Babylon → West Nottingham Academy (post-grad)Averaged 26.1 points — Suffolk’s highest average — with 5.3 rebounds, 4.3 assists and 2.7 steals, and reached 1,000 career points. Taking a post-grad year in Maryland and reclassified to the class of 2027.
- JJ Smith, William Floyd → North Country CC (NJCAA)Averaged 14.5 points, 5.3 rebounds and 4.7 assists for a 20-win Floyd team, and 17.8 points across four playoff games. Listed on North Country’s roster as Justin Smith.
- Sharod Sutton Jr., William Floyd → Dutchess CC (NJCAA)Averaged 16.6 points, 7.4 rebounds and 5.7 assists, and helped Floyd reach the county final as Suffolk Class AAA’s top seed.
- Brian Vales, Mount Sinai → RPI (D3)Averaged 21.6 points and 10 rebounds, and led Mount Sinai to a second straight Suffolk Class A title.
- Pete Mastando, Manhasset → University of Michigan (not playing basketball)Averaged 19.9 points and about 7 rebounds, and 31 points a game across three Nassau playoff elimination games. He is at Michigan as a student and is not playing college basketball (per Ted, Nov. 12, 2026).
- Sae’vion Ward, Southampton → Suffolk CC (NJCAA — enrolling January)Averaged 18.7 points with 46 three-pointers, about 7 assists and about 5 steals, and helped Southampton win the Suffolk Class B title. He is taking the fall semester off and enrolling at Suffolk County Community College in January (per Ted, Nov. 12, 2026).
The only non-seniors on Newsday’s teams — First Team junior Mical Saint-Jean of Baldwin and Second Team junior Kyle Edmundson of Kings Park — return to their high schools for the 2026-27 season.
← Back To High School Page